Carbon Nanotube Qubits Shatter Coherence Records: The Quantum Computing Dark Horse That Could Change Everything
The quantum computing landscape just witnessed a seismic shift. While tech giants like IBM and Google have dominated headlines with their superconducting qubit achievements, a lesser-known material has quietly emerged as a potential game-changer. Carbon nanotube qubits have achieved a breakthrough coherence time of 1.3 microseconds, representing a staggering 100-fold improvement over previous carbon-based quantum systems.
Listen to the podcast instead, 16mins -available on Spotify & Apple.
This milestone, reported by researchers from French startup C12 and École Normale Supérieure in Nature Communications, places carbon nanotubes squarely in competition with established quantum computing platforms. The achievement signals a potential paradigm shift in quantum hardware, where the race for quantum supremacy might be won not by scaling existing technologies, but by fundamentally reimagining the building blocks of quantum computers.
The implications extend far beyond academic curiosity. With quantum computing market forecasts predicting 25% compound annual growth through 2034 and global investment projected to surge by 9% in 2025, this breakthrough could reshape competitive dynamics across the entire quantum industry. The question isn't whether carbon nanotubes will impact quantum computing, but whether they'll become the foundation for the next generation of quantum processors.
The Coherence Game: Why Every Microsecond Matters
Quantum computing's greatest challenge isn't processing power or algorithm complexity. It's time. Specifically, coherence time - the fleeting window during which qubits maintain their quantum properties before environmental interference destroys their delicate superposition states.
Every quantum computer faces this fundamental constraint. Researchers from C12 and ENS (École Normale Supérieure) have published findings in Nature Communications demonstrating coherent control of quantum states within a carbon-based circuit. The study reports a coherence time of approximately 1.3 microseconds for carbon nanotube qubits, a figure that transforms the entire competitive landscape.
The carbon nanotube breakthrough represents more than incremental progress. Previous carbon-based quantum systems struggled with coherence times measured in nanoseconds, relegating them to laboratory curiosities. The 1.3-microsecond achievement catapults carbon nanotubes into direct competition with silicon spin qubits and approaches the performance of early superconducting systems.
The carbon device integrated into a microwave cavity maintained quantum coherence for up to 1.3 microseconds at 300 millikelvin without external magnetic fields. Analysis suggests cotunneling is the main source of decoherence, while charge noise and phonons played a lesser role due to the sophisticated isolation techniques employed by researchers.
The C12 Factor: From Lab Curiosity to Commercial Reality
Behind this breakthrough stands C12, a French quantum computing startup that has raised €18 million to commercialize carbon nanotube quantum processors. Founded in 2020 by the Desjardins brothers, Pierre and Matthieu, who serve as its chief executive and chief technology officer respectively, the startup is pioneering the development of a carbon nanotube-based quantum computer. The company was spun out of the physics laboratory of the École Normale Supérieure.
C12's approach differs fundamentally from quantum computing incumbents. Unlike other quantum computers, we use carbon nanotubes as the fundamental building block of our processor. By combining the power of an ultra-pure material with an easy-to-manufacture semiconductor device, we are building a scalable platform for quantum computing.
The company's technology roadmap appears aggressive yet realistic. C12 aims to release its first five-qubit chip by 2025, with a long-term vision of building large-scale, error-corrected quantum computers using its patented nano-assembly technique. "Our vision is that all big revolutions in computing start with a material breakthrough," said Pierre Desjardins.
This timeline positions C12 to deliver commercial quantum hardware within months, not years. The company's nano-assembly technique addresses one of quantum computing's persistent challenges: manufacturing consistency. With this technique, the devices we create are made up of carbon nanotubes connected between electrical contacts, suspended above an array of gate electrodes. This ensures the nanotubes are maximally isolated from the environment, drastically reducing decoherence due to charge and mechanical noise.
Technical Deep Dive: What Makes Carbon Nanotubes Special
Carbon nanotubes possess unique properties that make them ideal quantum computing candidates. Their atomically perfect structure provides natural confinement for quantum states, while their isotopic purity minimizes nuclear spin interactions that plague other qubit platforms.
The recent breakthrough leveraged circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED) techniques, coupling carbon nanotube spin qubits to microwave cavity photons. This approach enables precise control and readout of quantum states while maintaining isolation from environmental decoherence sources.
Carbon nanotubes allow for the creation of high-quality qubits with minimal charge noise, making them ideal for maintaining quantum coherence, crucial for building reliable quantum computers. The material's inherent properties address several fundamental challenges that have limited other qubit platforms.
Research indicates that further improvements are possible. Further advancements, potentially involving isotopically purified ¹²C nanotubes and high-impedance resonators, could enable high-fidelity quantum gates and extended coherence times. This suggests the 1.3-microsecond achievement represents an initial milestone rather than a fundamental limit.
Market Implications: A New Player in the Quantum Race
The carbon nanotube breakthrough arrives at a crucial moment for the quantum computing industry. In 2024, the QT industry saw a shift from growing quantum bits (qubits) to stabilizing qubits, marking a turning point. It signals to mission-critical industries that QT could soon become a safe and reliable component of their technology infrastructure.
This shift from quantity to quality plays directly into carbon nanotubes' strengths. While competitors focus on scaling qubit counts, C12's approach prioritizes stability and coherence - the foundation upon which all quantum algorithms depend.
The financial implications are significant. The financial industry is poised to become an early adopter of quantum computing. As 2024 ends, we reflect on recent developments and trends expected to continue through 2025, identifying six key trends from 2024 reports and announcements.
Investment patterns suggest growing confidence in alternative quantum approaches. French startup C12 develops quantum processors using carbon nanotubes as their building blocks. The startup grows ultrapure carbon nanotubes atom by atom to suppress noise from nuclear-electron spin coupling. It integrates these nanotubes onto silicon chips through a patented nano-assembly technique that could enable mass production.
Competitive Landscape: How Carbon Stacks Up
The quantum computing hardware landscape remains fragmented, with multiple competing technologies vying for dominance. Carbon nanotubes now join this competition with credible performance metrics:
This positioning places carbon nanotubes in the competitive middle tier, with significant room for improvement. The record long coherence time of 8.2 µs and spin-lattice relaxation time of 13 ms of these electronic spin qubits allow demonstration of quantum control operation manifested as Rabi oscillation. Investigation of the decoherence mechanism reveals an intrinsic coherence time of tens of milliseconds.
Manufacturing Advantages: The CMOS Connection
Carbon nanotubes offer a unique advantage in quantum computing manufacturing: compatibility with existing semiconductor fabrication processes. This compatibility could accelerate commercialization and reduce production costs compared to exotic platforms requiring specialized facilities.
A full prototype is expected in 2024. Additionally, CEA and C12 claim to have demonstrated for the first time ever the capability to manufacture in volume core components to calibrate, control and read qubits using standard (presumably CMOS) processes. The nanotubes are assembled mechanically using techniques that leverage existing semiconductor infrastructure.
This manufacturing compatibility addresses a critical bottleneck in quantum computing commercialization. While superconducting systems require complex dilution refrigeration and ion traps demand precise laser control, carbon nanotube qubits can potentially be manufactured using modified versions of existing chip fabrication equipment.
Looking Forward: The Path to Quantum Advantage
The carbon nanotube breakthrough raises fundamental questions about the future of quantum computing. Will quantum advantage emerge from scaling existing platforms, or will material innovations like carbon nanotubes enable entirely new approaches?
Industry observers note that quantum computing's history is littered with promising technologies that failed to scale. However, carbon nanotubes' unique combination of coherence, manufacturability, and material stability suggests they could overcome historical limitations.
Quantum computing, new energy sources, and AI agents: 2025 is set to be defined by a renewed drive for potentially disruptive technologies, with global technology investment projected to grow by 9 percent, according to Gartner.
The next 18 months will prove crucial. C12's planned five-qubit chip release in 2025 will demonstrate whether carbon nanotube qubits can maintain their performance advantages in integrated systems. Success could trigger a wave of investment and research into carbon-based quantum computing.
Applications and Use Cases: Where Carbon Nanotubes Shine
The 1.3-microsecond coherence time opens several immediate applications for carbon nanotube qubits. Quantum sensing, where extended coherence directly translates to measurement sensitivity, represents a natural fit. Financial modeling, optimization problems, and cryptographic applications could all benefit from the improved stability.
Gating a single CNT can produce a spin-, charge-, or phonon-based qubit possessing a long coherence time and a high-quality-factor resonance, which is promising for sensitive magnetometry, quantum gates, and optomechanical nanocircuits.
The versatility of carbon nanotube qubits extends beyond traditional quantum computing applications. Their compatibility with photonic systems enables hybrid quantum-classical architectures that could bridge the gap between current classical systems and future fault-tolerant quantum computers.
Investment Implications: The Quantum Gold Rush
The carbon nanotube breakthrough occurs amid unprecedented quantum computing investment. Quantum computing promises a revolution in computational capabilities. This accessible quantum computing market report evaluates key technologies, companies, drivers for growth and adoption barriers across this emerging industry. Multiple competing quantum computer technologies are assessed: superconducting, silicon-spin, photonic, trapped-ion, neutral-atom, topological, diamond-defect, and annealing.
Investors now face a portfolio decision: concentrate on established platforms with proven scaling paths, or diversify into alternative approaches like carbon nanotubes that offer potential breakthrough performance. The 100-fold coherence improvement suggests carbon nanotubes deserve serious consideration in any quantum computing investment strategy.
Challenges and Limitations: The Road Ahead
Despite the breakthrough, carbon nanotube qubits face significant challenges. Manufacturing consistency remains difficult, with nanotube diameter and chirality variations affecting qubit performance. Integration with classical control electronics requires sophisticated interface circuits that add complexity and cost.
Scaling beyond single qubits to functional quantum processors will test carbon nanotubes' commercial viability. While the 1.3-microsecond coherence time is impressive, it remains orders of magnitude below trapped ion systems and lacks the extensive error correction research that supports superconducting platforms.
The path from laboratory demonstration to commercial quantum computer is notoriously difficult. Many promising quantum technologies have failed to navigate the transition from research prototype to manufactured product. Carbon nanotubes' success depends on overcoming these practical challenges while maintaining their coherence advantages.
The Quantum Future: Carbon's Role
The carbon nanotube breakthrough represents more than a technical achievement. It demonstrates that quantum computing's future remains open, with multiple viable paths to quantum advantage. The 1.3-microsecond coherence time places carbon nanotubes in serious contention for next-generation quantum processors.
Industry consolidation appears inevitable as the quantum computing market matures. Carbon nanotubes' unique properties position them as potential acquisition targets for tech giants seeking to diversify their quantum portfolios. The technology's manufacturing compatibility makes it attractive to semiconductor companies looking to leverage existing fabrication capabilities.
The quantum computing race is far from over. Carbon nanotubes have emerged as a credible dark horse, offering a combination of performance, manufacturability, and scalability that could reshape the entire industry. Whether they fulfill this promise depends on execution, investment, and the ongoing evolution of quantum computing requirements.
Conclusion: The Quantum Paradigm Shift
The carbon nanotube qubit breakthrough marks a pivotal moment in quantum computing history. A 100-fold improvement in coherence time transforms carbon from laboratory curiosity to commercial contender. C12's aggressive commercialization timeline and significant funding suggest this isn't merely academic research but a serious challenge to quantum computing incumbents.
The implications extend beyond quantum computing to the broader technology industry. If carbon nanotubes prove scalable, they could democratize quantum computing by enabling production using existing semiconductor facilities. This accessibility could accelerate quantum adoption across industries currently excluded by high costs and specialized requirements.
The next chapter in quantum computing's evolution is being written now. Carbon nanotubes have earned their place in this story, offering a compelling alternative to established platforms. Their success or failure will help determine whether quantum computing's future lies in scaling existing technologies or embracing entirely new approaches.
For investors, engineers, and industry observers, the carbon nanotube breakthrough serves as a reminder that quantum computing's most significant advances often come from unexpected directions. In a field where coherence is king, carbon nanotubes have demonstrated they're ready to compete for the crown.
What do you think about carbon nanotubes' potential in quantum computing? Have you considered how this breakthrough might impact your industry or investment strategy? Share your thoughts in the comments below and subscribe for more quantum computing insights.
